Skipping a bunch of steps, we started by rolling out the cookie dough, and using cute Christmas cookie cutters. (We used this recipe for Soft Cut-Out Sugar Cookies if you'd like to try it at home.)
Cutting out the cookie shapes, very simple!
Variety of Christmas cookie shapes. My favorite is the Christmas light.
So the Christmas cookies were baked, and really, we had no difficulty with these. They were thin and crispy, but moist when you bit into them. The shapes were really cute too, and we were able to get as many possible cookies out of our dough.
As the cookies were cooling, we moved on to make homemade icing: Royal Icing for Sugar Cookies.
This was the real treat and challenge of this MIHM baking project, as my mom and I have never really worked with homemade icing before. The recipe was simple enough, and after mixing everything together with a hand mixer, we had icing ready to go.
We planned to put the icing in little bottles for easy use, and use food coloring to have white frosting, green frosting, and red frosting. But guess what? Our food coloring was bad...as in hard, chunky, stuck to the bottle, etc. STRIKE 1. So we sent the MIHM Holiday Intern (aka my brother) to the store to get some food coloring at 8:30 p.m. He came back with pastel food coloring because the store didn't have standard Red, Blue, Green, Yellow food coloring. STRIKE 2. So here we were, 9 p.m. on a Monday night, all the frosting odds stacked against us. It's ok! MIHM will prevail! We broke out all of the sprinkles we had, and got to decorating the sugar cookies.
See how easy the frosting looks above? Yeah. It's not. Between my sticky fingers and runny frosting messes on the counter, I really slacked on the photography part of this project. Here's the issue. The more liquidy your frosting, the more it runs off the cooking past the point of no return. Even after you think you've put just the right amount on, added your sprinkles, and called it a day, nope...the frosting is not done moving around on your cookie. We used the squirt bottles, toothpicks and knives to frost the cookies. I think the toothpicks were probably the easiest to manage.
In the meantime, imagine if your Girls Team partner is yelling words of "encouragement" like, "take your time, try to make it look professional, don't make it look like a Kindergartener's, be creative" etc. etc. etc. All of this leads to a bad MIHM. I was TRYING to be creative. I was TRYING to make my cookie look like it was decorated by a 27 year old. I was TRYING to stay in the lines. It's IMPOSSIBLE.
Apparently it is possible though, because after my Girls Team partner had her own issues with the frosting, she reached out to Google where she would find that you are supposed to make two frostings. One: a thicker frosting you use to line your cookie shape. Two: a thinner frosting (like the one we made) to fill in the cookie. And also, you were supposed to wait a while for each part to dry before creating more designs on the cookie. SIGH. I don't know you guys. It just seems like a lot of work when they sell frosting at the grocery store...So, STRIKE 3.
Regardless of the disaster that was Royal Icing, my mom is up for trying it again. I need some time to think about it. But, our cookies did turn out cute, and despite looking a bit amateur hour, were actually very tasty! The icing was really sweet the night we made it, but was toned down some in the days to follow.
So here's a nice picture of some of our best work. No need to spoil the fun by positing some of the worst. :)
MERRY CHRISTMAS FROM MAKE IT HAPPEN MONDAY!








































